Home and Homeland: What Makes a Home?
When Israel contemplates changing the status of parts of the West Bank—some call it annexation, while others speak of extending Israeli law or sovereignty over parts of the territory—it provides an opportunity to pause, deepen our understanding of the many perspectives on the issue, and to reflect on the big questions that emerge for each of us and our connections to Israel.
WHAT IS HOME?
Often the discussion about territory and borders focuses on politics and strategy, as it should. It's important, however, to keep in mind the two words that come together to create a key term: homeland. What is it about this land that conjures such powerful images and feelings of home for so many people? Hebrew and Arabic share similar words for “home”—bayit in Hebrew, bait in Arabic—and both carry connotations of a physical place as well as a sense of being and belonging.
What is home to me might also be home to someone else, and that is where the tension lies: what happens when our perspectives and understandings of home—both physical and emotional—are being challenged?
The Hebrew word acher (other) holds within it the word ach (brother), signaling an intertwined connection between the familiar and the unfamiliar, the I and the thou. Embedded in shared letters (א-ח), ach and acher also come from different roots (א.ח.ר and א.ח.י), highlighting the individual expression of voices and the inherent tensions between brother and other.
Below are some poems and texts that invite us to explore all the possible feelings, big questions, and tensions we may be experiencing.
This collection of background articles and opinion writing examines the issue from multiple perspectives. We hope you’ll pursue more than one, and consider these questions:
- How do we approach sensitive issues? How do we listen to others’ views?
- How do different parties to the issue feel about the territory in question? How do you feel about it?
- This issue is one piece of the larger story of two peoples’ claims to one land. What options can you imagine for reconciling the conflicting claims?
Israel Could Annex Parts of the West Bank on July 1. Here’s What You Need to Know (Jewish Telegraphic Agency)
The Key Points of the Trump Middle East Peace Plan, Explained (Jewish Telegraphic Agency)
What Israel and Palestine Will Look Like According to Trump’s Plan map and link to full text (Haaretz)
We’ll Defend Annexation if Needed, But Here’s the Thing by Jason Isaacson, AJC
Criticizing Israel with Anguish and Love by Yossi Klein-Halevi
Abbas, Do Not Squander the Last Vestiges of a Fading Opportunity by Alon Ben-Meir
Legal Ramifications if Israel Decided to Annex the West Bank by Yuval Shany, Israel Democracy Institute
Is Annexation Really Good for the Jews? by former Jewish Agency Chairman Sallai Meridor
A Plea to Gantz, Ashkenazi: Israel and its Friends Need You to Block Annexation by Yossi Klein-Halevi